The Second Coming by W B Yeats Critical Analysis, Summary and Line-by-Line Explanation

The Second Coming by W B Yeats poem summary critical analysis explanation line by line English Literature Alok Mishra

W.B. Yeats, a towering figure in modernist literature, often infused his poetry with mysticism, symbolism, and reflections on the cyclical nature of history. One of his most compelling works, The Second Coming, is a profound meditation on societal collapse and the chaotic transition into a new epoch. Written in the aftermath of World War I, a period rife with political instability and social disintegration, the poem encapsulates Yeats’s fear of an impending apocalypse. In The Second Coming, the poet envisions a world where the established norms and structures crumble, giving way to an age of uncertainty and violence. The recurring motif of a “widening gyre” symbolises this spiralling out of control, a key concept in Yeats’s broader body of work where history is viewed as a series of recurring cycles marked by destruction and renewal. This poem, laden with apocalyptic imagery and esoteric allusions, provides a striking commentary on the fragility of civilisation, reflecting the profound anxieties of the early 20th century. In the following analysis, we will explore The Second Coming in detail, examining its themes, symbolism, and the historical context that influenced its creation.

The Second Coming, Publication Details:

W.B. Yeats’s The Second Coming was first published in 1920 in his collection The Tower, and this period marked Yeats’s maturity as a poet, reflecting profound philosophical meditations and historical reflections. The poem comprises 22 lines of free verse, devoid of any strict rhyme scheme, mirroring the chaotic and uncertain atmosphere it seeks to portray. Yeats famously regarded The Second Coming as a reflection on the disillusionment and decay following World War I and a forecast of even more significant upheaval. In a letter to a friend, he wrote that the poem sprang from his meditations on the cyclical nature of history and his belief in the breakdown of modern civilisation. Yeats’s prophetic tone and apocalyptic imagery cement The Second Coming as one of the most influential works in modernist poetry. Its publication during global instability—shortly after the Russian Revolution, the Irish War of Independence, and the Treaty of Versailles—solidifies its relevance to the poet’s contemporary context and broader human history.

Composed: 1919
Published: 1920
Poetry Collection: The Tower
Form: Free verse
Theme: Apocalypse, spiritual rebirth, and societal decay

The Second Coming, A Quick Summary of the Poem:

Yeats’s The Second Coming is a profound exploration of societal breakdown, spiritual disillusionment, and the cyclic nature of history. The poem begins with the speaker lamenting the collapse of order, using powerful, apocalyptic imagery to illustrate a world spiralling into chaos. The famous line, “Things fall apart; the centre cannot hold,” has become emblematic of the sense of disintegration that pervades much of the poem. Yeats presents the breakdown of human institutions and spiritual guidance, symbolising the end of one historical cycle and the beginning of another, one possibly darker and more ominous.

As the poem progresses, Yeats conjures the image of a “rough beast,” a powerful symbol of the new epoch about to be born. This “beast” heralds the dawn of a new, more dangerous age in which traditional values are upended. Drawing heavily from his theory of history as cyclical, with each era giving way to the next through a process of spiritual destruction and rebirth, Yeats envisions the “second coming” not as the return of Christ but as the arrival of a more sinister force that threatens to overshadow civilisation. The poem’s final lines reinforce the sense of dread and inevitability, suggesting that the future holds a terrifying and unredeemed fate for humanity.

The Second Coming, Stanza-by-Stanza Explanation and Critical Commentary:

Lines: 1-4
Turning and turning in the widening gyre
The falcon cannot hear the falconer;
Things fall apart; the centre cannot hold;
Mere anarchy is loosed upon the world.

Explanation:
The opening stanza of The Second Coming introduces the central metaphor of the “widening gyre,” a recurring image in Yeats’s work that symbolises history’s expanding, chaotic cycles. The falcon and falconer metaphor evokes a sense of loss of control and disconnect from established authority. The world is depicted as spinning out of balance, with no force able to restore order. The line “Things fall apart; the centre cannot hold” succinctly encapsulates the poem’s vision of societal collapse, as all central structures—moral, political, or spiritual—are disintegrating, paving the way for chaos and destruction.

Critical Commentary:
These opening lines set a powerful tone of apocalyptic dread. The “widening gyre” reflects Yeats’s belief in the cyclical nature of history, in which every cycle is marked by an upheaval that leads to the next. The falcon and falconer metaphor introduces the theme of the breakdown of human control over events. The line “Mere anarchy is loosed upon the world” emphasises the total breakdown of order in nature and human affairs. Yeats captures the anxiety of a world in turmoil following World War I, foreshadowing even greater catastrophes to come.

Notes on Poetic Prowess:
Yeats employs powerful imagery and metaphors to convey a sense of impending doom. The “widening gyre” suggests the centrifugal force pulling everything apart, and the alliteration of “falcon” and “falconer” adds to the sense of disintegration. The terse, declarative structure of the lines mirrors the poem’s thematic content: a collapse of meaning, coherence, and structure.

Comparison with Other Poets:
Yeats’s vision of an impending apocalypse is similar to T.S. Eliot’s The Waste Land, which features prominent themes of cultural collapse and spiritual desolation. Both poets use fragmented imagery and disjointed metaphors to depict a world on the brink of destruction, reflecting the disillusionment of the post-World War I generation.

Lines: 5-8
The blood-dimmed tide is loosed, and everywhere
The ceremony of innocence is drowned;
The best lack all conviction, while the worst
Are full of passionate intensity.

Explanation:
In these lines, Yeats further elaborates on the apocalyptic vision, describing the spread of violence and chaos. The “blood-dimmed tide” symbolises a flood of destruction that sweeps away the last remnants of innocence and order. Yeats mourns the loss of virtue, as the “best” people who should lead with integrity have lost their resolve. In contrast, the “worst” are brimming with dangerous zeal, pushing the world closer to catastrophe.

Critical Commentary:
These lines sharpen Yeats’s critique of the moral and political decay he saw around him. The imagery of the “blood-dimmed tide” suggests violence and a fundamental corruption of the moral fabric. The stark contrast between the “best” and “worst” intensifies the sense of helplessness, as those who might restore order are paralysed by doubt, while the worst are encouraged by their enthusiasm. This inversion of values reflects Yeats’s cynicism about the state of the modern world.

Notes on Poetic Prowess:
Yeats’s use of vivid, almost biblical imagery enhances the sense of apocalyptic foreboding. The phrase “blood-dimmed tide” evokes a flood of violence that obliterates everything in its path. The use of antithesis between the “best” and the “worst” reinforces the theme of societal inversion, where traditional virtues are rendered powerless in the face of unchecked aggression.

Comparison with Other Poets:
The idea that the “best lack all conviction” has echoes in works by other modernist poets, such as Ezra Pound, who, in Hugh Selwyn Mauberley, critiques the failure of intellectuals to counter the moral collapse of their age. Both Yeats and Pound saw the modern world as one in which the values of civilisation were overrun by barbarism.

Lines: 9-14
Surely some revelation is at hand;
Surely the Second Coming is at hand.
The Second Coming! Hardly are those words out
When a vast image out of Spiritus Mundi
Troubles my sight: somewhere in sands of the desert
A shape with lion body and the head of a man,

Explanation:
In these lines, the speaker anticipates a moment of spiritual revelation—the “Second Coming.” However, rather than a vision of redemption or divine intervention, Yeats introduces an image of a monstrous creature conjured from the collective unconscious (“Spiritus Mundi”). The creature, described as having the body of a lion and the head of a man, emerges as a symbol of the new era, one characterised by brutal and dehumanised forces.

Critical Commentary:
Yeats presents a deeply ironic vision of the “Second Coming,” inverting the Christian expectation of Christ’s return with the image of a bestial figure. This distortion underscores the poem’s dread, as the “revelation” is not one of salvation but of something more sinister. The reference to “Spiritus Mundi” suggests that this vision arises from the collective memory of humanity, implying that the new world order is one of violence and regression.

Notes on Poetic Prowess:
Yeats’s vivid description of the creature evokes ancient mythological symbols, and the phrase “troubles my sight” conveys the speaker’s horror at this vision of the future. Enjambment between lines enhances the sense of urgency and terror, propelling the reader towards the poem’s climax.

Comparison with Other Poets:
This monstrous vision recalls William Blake’s The Tyger, where the creature symbolises both beauty and terror. Yeats and Blake use the image of an animal to symbolise the divine and destructive forces at work in the universe, focusing on the ominous implications of these forces for humanity’s future.

Lines: 15-22
A gaze blank and pitiless as the sun,
Is moving its slow thighs, while all about it
Reel shadows of the indignant desert birds.
The darkness drops again; but now I know
That twenty centuries of stony sleep
Were vexed to nightmare by a rocking cradle,
And what rough beast, its hour come round at last,
Slouches towards Bethlehem to be born?

Explanation:
Yeats describes the creature’s “blank and pitiless” gaze in these final lines, emphasising its detachment from human emotions or morality. Its thighs’ slow, deliberate movement suggests an unstoppable force, indifferent to the destruction it brings. The image of the “rocking cradle” evokes the birth of Christ. Still, in a twisted inversion, it now signifies the awakening of this “rough beast,” symbolising the dawn of a new and terrifying era.

Critical Commentary:
The poem’s conclusion reinforces the apocalyptic tone, with the “rough beast” slouching towards Bethlehem, not a saviour but an anti-Christ figure whose arrival will herald the collapse of civilisation. The phrase “twenty centuries of stony sleep” refers to the period since the birth of Christ, suggesting that the Christian era has ended and a darker age is about to begin. Yeats’s use of the cradle as a symbol of birth and destruction encapsulates the poem’s central tension: the cyclical nature of history, where each end is also a beginning but not necessarily hopeful.

Notes on Poetic Prowess:
Using vivid, almost grotesque imagery to describe the beast—its “gaze blank and pitiless as the sun”—creates a sense of dread and inevitability. The final question, “What rough beast…slouches towards Bethlehem to be born?” leaves the reader with a sense of unease, as the future is depicted as both imminent and terrifying.

Comparison with Other Poets:
Yeats’s closing image of the “rough beast” compares with T.S. Eliot’s The Hollow Men, in which the world ends “not with a bang but a whimper.” Both poets express a profound disillusionment with the modern world and foresee a future in which traditional values have been obliterated, leaving only chaos and destruction.

The Second Coming by W.B. Yeats, a Comprehensive Critical Analysis:

W.B. Yeats’s “The Second Coming” is a profound meditation on the cyclical nature of history, the breakdown of societal order, and the dawning of a chaotic new era. Written in 1919 and published in 1920 in The Dial (periodical), this poem emerges from a post-World War I context, a period rife with social upheaval, political instability, and growing disillusionment. Marked by the poet’s characteristic use of mysticism, symbolism, and myth, The Second Coming epitomises Yeats’s vision of history as a series of cycles marked by destruction and renewal.

The poem is structured in two stanzas, each of unequal length, a departure from Yeats’s typically more rigid formal structures. This break from form reflects the thematic content of the poem itself—the world is falling apart, and traditional structures are no longer intact. The first stanza consists of eight lines, following a loose rhyme scheme, while the second stanza unfolds with fourteen lines, which flow without a strict pattern. The lack of a fixed structure mirrors the chaos Yeats perceives in the world around him.

The language in The Second Coming is rich with apocalyptic imagery and evokes a sense of impending doom. Yeats immediately plunges the reader into a scene of chaos with the opening line, “Turning and turning in the widening gyre.” The “gyre,” a concept central to Yeats’s mysticism, symbolises the cyclical progression of history. The widening gyre suggests a loss of control, a world spinning further and further away from its centre, where order and meaning have disintegrated. This powerful metaphor for historical cycles foreshadows the poem’s exploration of the collapse of civilisation.

Imagery and Symbolism: Yeats masterfully uses vivid, often violent imagery to heighten the sense of impending catastrophe. The “falcon” in the opening lines is one of the most striking symbols in the poem. Traditionally, the falcon represents vision, nobility, and control, but here, it has broken away from the falconer, symbolising the loss of order and control. The “blood-dimmed tide” and the phrase “mere anarchy is loosed upon the world” are powerful evocations of the chaos Yeats saw as enveloping his world. The phrase “the ceremony of innocence is drowned” suggests the obliteration of values, morality, and the sacred, replaced by destruction and moral decay.

The poem’s tone is one of mounting dread, heightened by Yeats’s use of paradoxical statements such as, “The best lack all conviction, while the worst / Are full of passionate intensity.” This contrast between the inertia of the righteous and the hunger of the corrupt reinforces the poem’s vision of a world turned upside down.

Allusions to Christian and Mythological Figures: The title itself alludes to the Christian concept of the Second Coming of Christ, an event prophesied in the Bible to mark the return of Christ to Earth. However, Yeats subverts this traditional religious narrative by suggesting that the second coming will not bring salvation but destruction. The “Spiritus Mundi,” or world spirit, which enters Yeats’s vision, conjures not a divine saviour but a “rough beast” that slouches towards Bethlehem, awaiting its birth. This image is a stark inversion of the Christian nativity, where instead of Christ, a monstrous creature will be born, signifying a new and terrifying epoch.

The rough beast can be seen as an allusion to various mythological or religious archetypes, particularly the Antichrist in Christian eschatology. It symbolises the inevitable decay and rebirth that Yeats believed characterised historical cycles. Its slow, deliberate movement towards Bethlehem indicates that this destructive force is not immediate, but its arrival is inevitable.

Historical and Political Context: While the poem draws on myth and religion, it also reflects the historical anxieties of the time it was written. Composed in the aftermath of World War I, Yeats witnessed a world where the old social and political orders had been shattered. The rise of totalitarian regimes, widespread disillusionment with traditional authority, and the violence of revolutionaries in Ireland contributed to a pervasive sense of instability. Yeats describes chaos in The Second Coming as metaphorical and literal, as nations crumbled and new, often more terrifying, forces rose to fill the void.

The phrase “Things fall apart; the centre cannot hold” captures this widespread sense of societal collapse. This line has since transcended the poem, becoming a frequently quoted expression of the breakdown of order in political and personal contexts. In the historical moment of its writing, this collapse was starkly evident in the disintegration of European monarchies, the Russian Revolution, and the growing unrest in Ireland, Yeats’s homeland.

Violence and Transformation: Like his earlier poem, Leda and the Swan, The Second Coming grapples with violence as a transformative force in history. In both poems, Yeats presents violent encounters—whether the brutal rape of Leda by Zeus or the cataclysmic events in The Second Coming—as necessary precursors to profound change. However, in The Second Coming, the transformation is not creative but destructive, as the “rough beast” signals the onset of a new dark age.

Yeats’s use of the word “slouching” to describe the beast’s movement towards Bethlehem emphasises the inevitability of this coming destruction. It suggests a creature indifferent to the devastation it brings, much like the beak in Leda and the Swan. The beast represents the culmination of the anarchy loosed upon the world, a new force that will replace the old yet offer no hope of renewal.

Interpretations and Scholarly Debate: Scholarly interpretations of The Second Coming often focus on the poem’s prophetic tone and its commentary on the cyclical nature of history. Some critics view the poem as an expression of Yeats’s disillusionment with the modern world, particularly during World War I. In contrast, others see it as a broader philosophical meditation on the inevitability of decay and rebirth.

The apocalyptic vision presented in The Second Coming has also led some to interpret the poem through the lens of Yeats’s involvement with the occult and his belief in historical cycles. His concept of the gyre, a spiralling cone representing the cyclical progression of history, plays a central role in this interpretation. According to Yeats’s mystical system, each age of history is marked by a 2,000-year cycle, and The Second Coming predicts the end of one such cycle, heralding the arrival of a new, darker epoch.

The Second Coming, Conclusion:

W.B. Yeats’s The Second Coming remains a powerful meditation on the cyclical nature of history, the breakdown of societal order, and the looming threat of a new, darker age. You can also add the fragility of civilisation and the inevitability of historical change to the list. The poem’s use of apocalyptic imagery, mythological allusions, and prophetic tone have made it a central work in modernist poetry, reflecting both the anxieties of the early 20th century and timeless concerns about human civilisation. Yeats’s vision of a world spinning out of control resonates with readers, as his “rough beast” seems always on the verge of arriving, ready to usher in a new and terrifying epoch.